Best Restaurants on Marco Island
(2026 Edition)
Looking for the best restaurants on Marco Island? From waterfront seafood to hidden Italian gems, here is every dining spot we cover, with a local profile for each. Find them all on the illustrated island map!
1. Arturo's Bistro
A proper sit-down dinner with live music
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
2. CJ's on the Bay
A gazebo-bar seat over Smokehouse Bay at sunset
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile3. Crazy Flamigo
Serves Burger and Seafood dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
4. Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano
Serves Italian dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile5. Dunkin'
Serves Donut and Coffee dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
6. Hoot's
A full breakfast and a table that's yours as long as you want it
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile7. Island Bistro
Serves French and Seafood dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
8. Marco Island Brewery
Forty taps, a pizza, and whatever game is on
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
10. Nacho Mama's
Tex-Mex upstairs at Marco Walk, with happy hour every day
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile11. Paradise Grill
Serves American dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile12. Philly Grill
Serves American and Burger dishes.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
13. 2Shea's Salty Dog Sports Bar & Grill
Catching a game with a plate of wings out of the sun
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile15. Sunset Grille
Local favorite on Marco Island.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
16. The Crazy Flamingo
A burger at the bar, no fuss
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
17. Snook Inn
Dockside grouper and live music under the chickee
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
18. Mango's Dockside Bistro
Fresh catch and key lime pie after a beach day
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
19. Marco Prime Steak and Seafood
Anniversary-grade steaks and a proper martini
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
20. The Oyster Society
Coastal seafood and raw bar.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
21. Pinchers
Florida seafood and crab house.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile22. Sami's of Marco
Casual local eatery.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile24. Italian Deli and Market
Italian deli and market.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile26. Island Gypsy Cafe and Marina Bar
Waterfront cafe and marina bar.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile27. Lee Be Fish
Seafood market and eatery.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile28. Quinn's on the Beach
Beachfront restaurant and bar.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile29. Sale e Pepe
Italian fine dining.
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local Profile
30. The Bar at 560
A locally crafted cocktail at the pool by the fire pits, or looking out over the Gulf
After dinner, find amazing things to do nearby!
View Local ProfileRestaurants on the Map
See Marco Island's restaurants on the map.
Dig Into a Themed Dining Guide
Craving something specific? Our local guides break the island's dining scene down further.